Medifast Brownie Recipes – Review

I have to say that out of all of the Medifast food that I have tried, the brownie is my absolute favorite!! I love it. Seriously LOVE IT!! I have one every day and have found different ways to make it.

You can make it as directed and it comes out as a cake like brownie. This is not one of my favorite ways to make it but it tastes good this way. I have just found other ways to make it that I like better.

You can make it as a shake. I love it this way. It is very filling and tastes very good. My favorite is a Reese’s Peanut Butter shake. You blend 1 cup of unsweetened almond milk or water, one wedge of laughing cow cream cheese, 1 tbsp of  Walden Farms chocolate syrup, 2 Tbsp of of PB2 (powdered peanut butter), 1 cup of ice. Blend all of this together and add a dolap of whipped cream to the top. This shake is pure deliciousness on a hot summer day!!

brownie peanut butter shake

Another way that I like to make it I did for the longest time if you don’t want to use any condiments. I would fix it as directed in the little paper cup that they provide and microwave it for 3o sec and then stick it in the freezer for 30 min. This recipe is a fudgy delicious one.

Medifast Brownie


I love the taste of chocolate and peanut butter together. There is nothing more rich or satisfying to me than those flavors. I just LOVE them. So, this is one of my favorite ways to make it. I make it as directed above, but add a dolap of PB2 (powdered peanut butter) to the middle of it and cover it with more brownie mix. It comes out as a mock Reese’s peanut butter cup. YUMMY!!

peanut butter brownie

Peanut butter cup brownie tastes heavenly.

Another way I have found lately online, is to combine the brownie with a chocolate chip pancake. It makes two Medifast meals, so I will either eat this when I need to get two in or you will cut it in half and eat half now and half later. Both are great options. I combine the two mixes in a bowl with 1/4 cup of water.

Medifast Stone Wave Brownie

I will put it in my StoneWave in the microwave and heat for 1 min and 30 sec. Let that sit for a min and plop it on my plate. This tastes great topped with some PB2 or laughing cow cinnamon cream cheese light.

Stone Wave brownie with laughing cow cream cheese

Finished Stone Wave brownie with light cinnamon laughing cow cream cheese.

However you decide to make the Medifast brownie, you typically can’t go wrong. It is absolutely my favorite and the only one that I eat everyday without fail.

What are some of your diet plan favorites, and do they help you stay on track?


1 Chron. 28:10 “Be strong and do the work.” Jeremiah 29:11 “For I know the plans I have for you,” declares the Lord, “plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you a hope and a future.”

Medifast has some deals for you! If you use my code, ITSUX56, and sign up for Medifast Advantage when you order $250+, you’ll receive 56 free Medifast Meals and free shipping! You’ll receive 28 free meals with your first Medifast Advantage order and ANOTHER 28 free meals with your next order! This offer is only valid if you enroll in Medifast Advantage, and it’s limited to one per customer. It’s not valid with prior purchases, any other promotions or discounts, or for Medifast Ready-to-Drink Shakes. Not ready to enroll in Medifast Advantage? You can use code ITSUX28 to receive 28 free meals with your purchase of over $250. Limit one per customer. This offer is limited to new customers only and not valid with prior purchases, Medifast Advantage, or any other promotions or discounts.  See website for complete details on program and discounts. Consult your physician before beginning a weight-loss program.

Like this post? Share it!